Local Insurance Experts for Homes, Vehicles & Families in Sarasota, FL
Your Local Experts for Home, Auto, Flood, Life & Recreational Insurance
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Sarasota, Florida
At Florida We Insure Agency – Mayer Insurance, we help Sarasota families protect what matters most with personalized coverage from 30+ top-rated Florida carriers. Whether you're insuring a coastal home, condo, car, boat, RV, or securing your family's financial future with life insurance, our Sarasota team provides the right protection at the right price.
As an independent insurance agency, we compare rates across multiple carriers to ensure you always receive the best value — automatically, year after year.
Services
Personal Insurance Services in Sarasota
Homeowners Insurance in Sarasota
Protect your coastal home, condo, or waterfront property with coverage designed for hurricane winds, floods, fire, theft, and more.
Auto Insurance in Sarasota
From basic liability to full coverage, we help Sarasota drivers secure affordable, reliable auto insurance.
Flood, Hurricane & Wind Insurance
Essential storm protection for residents of Siesta Key, Longboat Key, Lido Key, and coastal Sarasota neighborhoods.
Boat, RV & Specialty Vehicle Insurance
Coverage for boats, RVs, motorcycles, jet skis, and golf carts — ideal for Sarasota’s outdoor and waterfront lifestyle.
Life Insurance in Sarasota
Protect your family’s future with term life, whole life, and final-expense options tailored for Florida residents.
WHY CHOOSE US
Why Sarasota Families Choose Florida We Insure Agency
Independent Agency Advantage
We shop 30+ carriers to find the best home, auto, flood, life, or recreational insurance coverage.
Local Knowledge
We understand Sarasota’s unique insurance risks — from coastal flooding to hurricane zones to high-value home protection.
Annual Policy Re-Shopping
We automatically re-shop your coverage every renewal to ensure competitive pricing year after year.
Claims Advocacy With Legal Support
If your claim is delayed or denied, our in-house legal support team advocates on your behalf — at no extra cost.
Real Local Agents
No call centers — just friendly, licensed Florida agents who understand Sarasota’s neighborhoods and coastal challenges.
ABOUT THE OFFICE
About Our Sarasota Office
Florida We Insure – Mayer Insurance Agency
Proudly serving:
Sarasota
Siesta Key
Anastasia Island
Lido Key
Lakewood Ranch
Gulf Gate
Bee Ridge
and nearby communities
Meet the team
What Our St. Augustine Business Clients Are Saying
5.0 Stars from 120+ Happy Clients
Amanda P., Sarasota
“They made the process so easy. Great rates and excellent service.”
Mark D., Lakewood Ranch
“The Sarasota team explained everything clearly and found us better coverage for less.”
Get a Quote in Sarasota Today
Let us help you protect your home, vehicles, lifestyle, and family — in minutes.
