Local Insurance Experts for Homes, Vehicles & Families in St. Augustine, FL

Your Local Experts for Home, Auto, Flood, Life & Recreational Insurance

A framed picture hanging on the wall displays a handshake.

Your Trusted Insurance Partner in St. Augustine, Florida

At Florida We Insure Agency – Mayer Insurance, we help St. Augustine families protect what matters most with personalized coverage from 30+ top-rated Florida carriers. Whether you’re insuring a historic home, coastal property, car, boat, or securing your family’s future with life insurance, our team delivers the right protection at the right price.


As an independent insurance agency, we compare rates across multiple carriers to ensure you always get the best coverage — automatically, year after year.

Services

Personal Insurance Services in St. Augustine

Group of people under a house icon.

Homeowners Insurance in St. Augustine

Get protection tailored for historic homes, coastal properties, flood zones, and hurricane-prone areas.

Black car icon on white background.

Auto Insurance in St. Augustine

From basic liability to full coverage, we help St. Augustine drivers secure affordable, reliable auto insurance.

Black cloud with raindrops and lightning.

Flood, Hurricane & Wind Insurance

Essential storm protection for homeowners in Anastasia Island, Vilano Beach, St. Augustine Beach, and surrounding coastal zones.

Silhouette of a boat on waves, with a cabin, flag, and windows.

Boat, RV & Specialty Vehicle Insurance

Coverage for boats, RVs, motorcycles, golf carts, and more — perfect for St. Augustine’s coastal lifestyle.

Person icon with heartbeat and plus sign.

Life Insurance in St. Augustine

Protect your family’s financial future with term life, whole life, and final-expense plans designed for Florida residents.

WHY CHOOSE US

Why Choose Florida We Insure Agency in St. Augustine?

  • Independent Agency Advantage

    We shop 30+ carriers to find the best policy for your home, auto, life, flood, or recreational coverage.

  • Local Knowledge

    We understand St. Augustine’s unique risks — from coastal flooding to hurricane zones to historic home requirements.

  • Annual Policy Re-Shopping

    We automatically re-shop your coverage every renewal to keep your rate competitive.

  • Claims Advocacy With Legal Support

    If your claim is delayed or denied, our in-house legal support team advocates for YOU — at no extra cost.

  • Real Local Agents

    No call centers — just friendly, licensed agents who live and work in Florida.

ABOUT THE OFFICE

About Our St. Augustine Office

Florida We Insure – Mayer Insurance Agency

Black location pin icon.

St. Augustine, FL

Black telephone handset with sound waves.
Black envelope icon.
Black clock face indicating time is approximately 4:05.

Monday–Friday: 9am–5pm

Proudly serving:

Black location pin icon.

St. Augustine

Black location marker.

Vilano Beach

Black location pin.

Anastasia Island

Black location pin icon.

Palm Valley & nearby communities

Meet the team

What Our St. Augustine Business Clients Are Saying
Five black stars in an arch.

 5.0 Stars from 120+ Happy Clients

Empty white space.

Sarah L., St. Augustine

“Florida We Insure made everything seamless. Great rates and even better service.”

James W., Jacksonville

“They truly care. When I had a claim, they fought for me. I’ll never switch.”

Black telephone handset with radiating sound waves.

Get a Quote in St. Augustine Today

Let us help you protect your home, vehicle, lifestyle, and family — in minutes.